A risky challenge for intransitive preferences
نویسندگان
چکیده
Philosophers have spent a great deal of time debating whether intransitive preferences can be rational. I present risky decision that poses challenge for the defender intransitivity. The intransitivity faces trilemma and must either: (i) reject rationality preferences, (ii) deny State-wise Dominance, or (iii) accept bizarre verdict you required to pay relabel tickets fair lottery. If we take first horn, then synchronic refutation intransitivity, an improvement on widely criticized diachronic arguments. sketch possible responses may rescue argue each response is but generates explanatory debt. conclude by showing how here clarifies foundations theory without transitivity, conditional some debt being payable.
منابع مشابه
A Model for Intransitive Preferences
It is known that humans form non-transitive preferences. We propose to model human preferences as a complete weighted directed graph where nodes are objects of preference, and an edge leading from one node to another has weight equal to the probability that the destination node will be preferred (or chosen) from the pair connected by the edge. We also propose that the most preferred object(s) m...
متن کاملNeural Signatures of Intransitive Preferences
It is often assumed that decisions are made by rank-ordering and thus comparing the available choice options based on their subjective values. Rank-ordering requires that the alternatives' subjective values are mentally represented at least on an ordinal scale. Because one alternative cannot be at the same time better and worse than another alternative, choices should satisfy transitivity (if a...
متن کاملApproval Voting with Intransitive Preferences
We extend Approval voting to the settings where voters may have intransitive preferences. The major obstacle to applying Approval voting in these settings is that voters are not able to clearly determine who they should approve or disapprove, due to the intransitivity of their preferences. An approach to address this issue is to apply tournament solutions to help voters make the decision. We st...
متن کاملCommentary: “Neural signatures of intransitive preferences”
Kalenscher et al. (2010) explored the neural signatures of intransitive preferences. This endeavor is of great interest because transitivity of preferences has long been considered a key feature of rationality. The success of this approach hinges upon appropriate methods for identifying decision makers with intransitive preferences. The authors invented a descriptive numerical “index of intrans...
متن کاملRisky business: rhesus monkeys exhibit persistent preferences for risky options
Rhesus monkeys have been shown to prefer risky over safe options in experiential decision-making tasks. These findings might be due, however, to specific contextual factors, such as small amounts of fluid reward and minimal costs for risk-taking. To better understand the factors affecting decision-making under risk in rhesus monkeys, we tested multiple factors designed to increase the stakes in...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Noûs
سال: 2023
ISSN: ['1468-0068', '0029-4624']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/nous.12455